What if Jacob wasn’t the only one dreaming in Genesis? What if the entire book is a dream?
What if the dream of Jacob’s ladder is only the most explicit dream in Genesis?
But what if many—perhaps even all—of the biblical stories we’ve been reading in Genesis are dreams? This isn’t an idea from a contemporary scholar. It comes from none other than Moses Maimonides, author of the Thirteen Principles of Faith. Moses Maimonides offers a startling way to read the Bible: encounters with angels take place only in prophetic visions or dreams. Could that lens change how we understand many of the seminal stories in Genesis—and even the development of biblical ideas?
Geoffrey Stern and Rabbi Adam Mintz explore this possibility through Jewish teachings on dreams and the work of Freud, Jung, and Otto Rank. If these stories are dreams of a people, what might they reveal about our deepest struggles? And does reading them this way make them less valuable—or more?
Join us for this week’s Madlik: Disruptive Torah on Parashat Vayetzei.
Key Takeaways
- Maimonides’ radical lens: Biblical encounters with angels—and even with God—may unfold in prophetic visions or dreams, inviting us to reread Genesis.
- Dreams reflect the heart: The rabbis teach that our thoughts shape our dreams—and remind us that an uninterpreted dream is like an unread letter.
- A people can dream, too: Freud, Jung, and Otto Rank connect dreams with myth. Read this way, Genesis may reveal a culture working through its deepest struggles—and perhaps help us work through ours too.
Timestamps
[00:00] Are Bible Stories Dreams
[01:17] Abraham Angels And A Dream
[02:25] Jacob Ladder Vision
[04:11] Maimonides Angel Rule
[15:21] Akedah As Nightmare
[16:48] Dreams Interpreted In Dreams
[21:00] Talmud Dream Practices
[23:23] Dream Wisdom And Maxims
[28:58] Freud Jung And Myth
[32:42] Closing And Next Week
Links & Learnings
Sign up for free and get more from our weekly newsletter https://madlik.com/
Sefaria Source Sheet: https://voices.sefaria.org/sheets/759051
Transcript here: https://madlik.substack.com/
1
00:00:00,492 –> 00:00:01,794
2
00:00:04,728 –> 00:00:08,680
Jacob falls asleep and dreams of a ladder to heaven.
3
00:00:08,680 –> 00:00:11,902
In Jacob’s dream, we know we’re in a dream.
4
00:00:11,902 –> 00:00:20,807
But what if many, perhaps all, of the biblical stories we’ve been reading in Genesis and
throughout the Bible are dreams?
5
00:00:20,807 –> 00:00:23,388
This isn’t an idea from a contemporary scholar.
6
00:00:23,388 –> 00:00:29,691
It comes from none other than Moses Maimonides, author of the Thirteen Principles of Faith.
7
00:00:29,712 –> 00:00:34,444
With the insights of the Talmud, Freud, Jung, and Otto Rank, we ask:
8
00:00:34,444 –> 00:00:40,161
Does seeing these stories as dreams make them less valuable or more?
9
00:00:40,223 –> 00:00:45,900
Can a people’s stories reveal and help resolve its deepest struggles?
00:00:48,002 –> 00:00:48,982
Welcome to Madlik.
11
00:00:48,982 –> 00:00:55,045
My name is Geoffrey Stern, and at Madlik we light a spark or shed some light on a Jewish
text or tradition.
12
00:00:55,045 –> 00:01:02,788
Along with Rabbi Adam Mintz, we host Madlik Disruptive Torah on your favorite podcast
platform and now on YouTube and Substack.
13
00:01:02,788 –> 00:01:08,050
We also publish a source sheet on Sefaria, and a link is included in the show notes.
14
00:01:08,050 –> 00:01:17,494
Join us as we explore this week’s Torah portion of Vayetzei and look at our traditions
through an entirely new lens.
15
00:01:17,494 –> 00:01:24,577
So, Rabbi, two Shabbats ago, I was in Israel, and I was all prepared to give a D’var
Torah.
16
00:01:24,577 –> 00:01:29,239
And it was the portion of Abraham welcoming the angels as guests.
17
00:01:29,239 –> 00:01:33,921
I mean, how good does it get when you’re sitting in somebody’s house as a guest, right?
18
00:01:33,921 –> 00:01:42,945
So all of a sudden, the guy before me, his name was Alex, he’s supposed to give the first
D’var Torah, and he asks, What’s the deal with Sodom?
19
00:01:42,945 –> 00:01:46,666
Abraham argues about Sodom, but he doesn’t argue
20
00:01:46,666 –> 00:01:48,227
about the Akedah.
21
00:01:48,227 –> 00:01:50,648
So now I can’t give my D’var Torah.
22
00:01:50,648 –> 00:01:52,449
I gotta answer his question.
23
00:01:52,449 –> 00:01:59,664
So I pulled the Rambam on him and I said, listen, they were both dreams because according
to Maimonides, they had angels in them.
24
00:01:59,664 –> 00:02:01,595
And we’re gonna get into that today.
25
00:02:01,595 –> 00:02:10,680
So really you gotta ask Abraham what was in his mind that in his mind he could argue with
God in one and then the other had to go through all this angst.
26
00:02:10,680 –> 00:02:11,891
So anyway, here I am.
27
00:02:11,891 –> 00:02:13,944
Now we’re actually gonna
28
00:02:13,944 –> 00:02:22,781
Provide the answer of the Rambam that I think almost turns the whole Torah, if not at
least Genesis, on its head.
29
00:02:22,781 –> 00:02:25,644
It all was a dream.
30
00:02:25,644 –> 00:02:29,187
So here we are, we’re in Genesis 28.
31
00:02:29,187 –> 00:02:32,650
Jacob left Beersheva and set out for Haran.
32
00:02:32,650 –> 00:02:38,504
He came upon a certain place and stopped there for the night, for the sun had set.
33
00:02:38,648 –> 00:02:44,586
Taking one of the stones of that place he put it under his head and lay down in that
place.
34
00:02:44,627 –> 00:02:55,776
In verse twelve it says, He had a dream, a stairway was set on the ground and its top
reached to the sky, and angels of God were going up and down on it.
35
00:02:55,776 –> 00:03:02,008
And standing beside him was God who said, I am the eternal, the God of your father,
Abraham and the God of Isaac.
36
00:03:02,008 –> 00:03:11,271
The ground upon which you are lying I will assign to you and to your offspring, your
descendants shall be as the dust of the earth, you shall spread out to the west, to the
37
00:03:11,271 –> 00:03:14,032
East, to the north, and to the south.
38
00:03:14,032 –> 00:03:21,364
Yamah va-kedmah ve-tzafonah va-negbah, that’s what the Chabadniks sing, Ufaratzta!
39
00:03:21,834 –> 00:03:26,259
All the families of the earth shall bless themselves by you and your descendants.
40
00:03:26,259 –> 00:03:35,927
Remember, I am with you, I will protect you wherever you go, I will bring you back to this
land, I will not leave you until I have done what I have promised you.
41
00:03:36,188 –> 00:03:37,669
Verse 16.
42
00:03:37,669 –> 00:03:44,575
Jacob awoke from his sleep and said, Surely God is present in this place, and I did not
know it.
43
00:03:44,575 –> 00:03:47,650
Shaken, he said, How awesome is this place?
44
00:03:47,650 –> 00:03:52,673
This is none other than the abode of God, and that is the gateway to heaven.
45
00:03:52,673 –> 00:04:03,598
Early in the morning, Jacob took the stone that he had put under his head, set it up as a
pillar, poured oil on the top of it, and he made a sacrifice.
46
00:04:03,598 –> 00:04:07,661
So this is clearly a story that is a dream.
47
00:04:07,661 –> 00:04:11,664
There’s no question about this story that it is a dream.
48
00:04:11,664 –> 00:04:15,902
But now we’re going to visit our friend Maimonides.
49
00:04:15,902 –> 00:04:17,943
In his Guide for the Perplexed.
50
00:04:17,943 –> 00:04:19,443
And I’m only showing the English.
51
00:04:19,443 –> 00:04:22,645
I always say this because the it was written in Arabic.
52
00:04:22,645 –> 00:04:26,767
So unless we read it in Arabic, the Hebrew’s just the same as the English.
53
00:04:26,767 –> 00:04:31,348
So Maimonides says as follows in Part Two, Chapter 42.
54
00:04:31,348 –> 00:04:40,912
We have already shown that the appearance or speech of an angel mentioned in Scripture
took place in a vision or a dream.
55
00:04:40,912 –> 00:04:45,438
It makes no difference whether this is expressly stated or not.
56
00:04:45,438 –> 00:04:51,060
As we have explained above, this is a point of considerable importance.
57
00:04:51,100 –> 00:04:55,882
In some cases, the account begins by stating that the prophet saw an angel.
58
00:04:55,882 –> 00:05:02,265
In others, the account apparently introduces a human being who ultimately is shown to be
an angel.
59
00:05:02,265 –> 00:05:04,166
But it makes no difference.
60
00:05:04,166 –> 00:05:15,018
For if the fact that an angel has been heard is only mentioned at the end, you may rest
satisfied that the whole account from the beginning describes a prophetic vision.
61
00:05:15,018 –> 00:05:26,503
In such visions, a prophet either sees God who speaks to him, as will be explained by us,
or sees an angel who speaks to him, or hears someone speaking to him without seeing the
62
00:05:26,503 –> 00:05:31,846
Speaker, or he sees a man who speaks to him and learns afterward that the speaker was an
angel.
63
00:05:31,846 –> 00:05:41,014
In this latter kind of prophecies, the prophet relates that he saw a man who was doing or
saying something, and that he learnt afterwards that it was an angel.
64
00:05:41,014 –> 00:05:47,520
So, Rabbi, this is a very broad and as Maimonides said, of considerable importance.
65
00:05:47,520 –> 00:05:53,705
If you find an angel in a story, it was a dream.
66
00:05:53,705 –> 00:06:02,812
Now, of course, that’s related to the fact that Maimonides is a rationalist. Angels are
dreams, because you can’t actually see an angel.
67
00:06:02,812 –> 00:06:04,313
Doesn’t mean anything.
68
00:06:04,313 –> 00:06:10,232
I agree, but I did start by saying … I could have picked Maimonides who wrote the Mishneh
Torah.
69
00:06:10,232 –> 00:06:16,265
But I picked Maimonides, who had the 13 attributes that we have to believe in for dogma.
70
00:06:16,265 –> 00:06:20,196
So Maimonides believes that the Messiah will come, you have to believe that.
71
00:06:20,196 –> 00:06:24,168
He has you believe that the dead will come back to life.
72
00:06:24,168 –> 00:06:37,584
And here he’s saying that in terms of what you need to believe in or don’t need to believe
in, if a story has an angel, you can assume that it occurred in the mind of the beholder,
73
00:06:37,584 –> 00:06:38,582
To put it
74
00:06:38,674 –> 00:06:41,415
That includes both visions and dreams.
75
00:06:41,415 –> 00:06:42,415
He goes on.
76
00:06:42,415 –> 00:06:52,478
This important principle was adopted by one of our sages, one of the most distinguished
among them, Rabbi Hiyya the Great, who said in Bereshit Rabbah, in the exposition of the
77
00:06:52,478 –> 00:06:57,459
Scriptural passage, commenting, and the Lord appeared to him in the plain of Mamre.
78
00:06:57,459 –> 00:07:07,522
So that literally was the parsha that happened two weeks ago when Abraham was sitting
outside the tent, seeing if he could pick up any guests.
79
00:07:07,586 –> 00:07:15,829
The general statement that the Lord appeared to Abraham is followed by the description in
what manner the appearance of the Lord took place.
80
00:07:15,829 –> 00:07:19,680
Namely Abraham saw first three men, he ran and spoke to them.
81
00:07:19,680 –> 00:07:30,843
Rabbi Hiyya, the author of the explanation, holds that the words of Abraham, my Lord, if
now I have found grace in thy sight, do not, I pray thee, pass from thy servant, were
spoken by him
82
00:07:30,843 –> 00:07:33,720
In a prophetic vision to one of the men.
83
00:07:33,720 –> 00:07:37,875
For he says that Abraham addressed these words to the chief of these men.
84
00:07:37,875 –> 00:07:41,639
Note this well, for it is one of the great mysteries of the Law.
85
00:07:41,639 –> 00:07:48,866
So it’s interesting because in this particular story, if you recall, it was first God that
came to Abraham.
86
00:07:48,866 –> 00:07:56,454
So you would think if we ever have an opportunity to say this was talking, as they would
say by Moses, panim el panim.
87
00:07:56,476 –> 00:07:57,227
No, no, no.
88
00:07:57,227 –> 00:08:03,252
As long as it goes from God to men.
89
00:08:03,252 –> 00:08:06,575
And then we find out that these three men are angels.
90
00:08:06,575 –> 00:08:11,179
He tags it on Rabbi Hiyya.
91
00:08:11,179 –> 00:08:21,709
I’m not sure you could attribute to Rabbi Hiyya this general rule that wherever there’s an
angel, but what Rabbi Hiyya does say is that even though it says, and God came to him,
92
00:08:21,709 –> 00:08:23,370
Know that it was
93
00:08:23,370 –> 00:08:24,310
an angel.
94
00:08:24,310 –> 00:08:31,213
The same I hold is the case when it is said in reference to Jacob and a man wrestled with
him.
95
00:08:31,213 –> 00:08:39,196
So now we’re going a little bit further in this story when Jacob comes back from his
sojourn with Laban and he fights with the angel.
96
00:08:39,196 –> 00:08:46,680
This too took place in a prophetic vision, since it is expressly stated at the end that it
was an angel.
97
00:08:46,680 –> 00:08:50,694
So there too, he’s saying, you might think he actually fought with the angel.
98
00:08:50,694 –> 00:08:53,096
Well, he did fight with him, but it was in a dream.
99
00:08:53,096 –> 00:08:55,798
He was struggling with the angel in his dreams.
100
00:08:55,798 –> 00:09:00,202
Now what’s important, Maimonides thinks that dreams are important.
101
00:09:00,202 –> 00:09:02,564
Don’t minimize the importance of dreams.
102
00:09:02,564 –> 00:09:04,725
It just never really happened.
103
00:09:05,287 –> 00:09:14,046
And that’s why I started in the intro by saying, does this make the stories less
significant or maybe more significant?
104
00:09:14,046 –> 00:09:15,648
That’s not the issue here.
105
00:09:15,648 –> 00:09:19,492
And I think that’s a little bit I think you hit the nail on the head.
106
00:09:19,492 –> 00:09:21,954
That’s the crux of our discussion.
107
00:09:22,225 –> 00:09:28,826
It says in another case, those in the vision of Abraham, where it says, and the Lord
appeared to him.
108
00:09:28,826 –> 00:09:31,785
That is followed by a detailed description.
109
00:09:31,785 –> 00:09:36,630
Similarly, the account of the vision of Jacob begins and the angels of God met him.
110
00:09:36,630 –> 00:09:40,651
And then follows a detailed description of how it came to pass that they met him.
111
00:09:40,651 –> 00:09:53,155
So we really are now going to see a bunch of stories, especially with Jacob, where the
night before he meets with Laban, the day or two before where he sends his messengers,
112
00:09:53,155 –> 00:09:55,916
Angels appear over and over again.
113
00:09:55,916 –> 00:10:03,518
By this term, man, one of the angels is meant, mentioned in the phrase, and the angels of
God met him.
114
00:10:03,578 –> 00:10:04,204
That
115
00:10:04,204 –> 00:10:11,238
Which happened to Balaam on the way, and the speaking of the donkey took place in a
prophetic vision.
116
00:10:11,238 –> 00:10:17,721
Since further on in the same account, an angel of God is introduced as speaking to Balaam.
117
00:10:17,721 –> 00:10:20,963
So now, Rabbi, your mind starts playing games on you.
118
00:10:20,963 –> 00:10:31,189
You start thinking back to all the stories we’ve read and we will read that seem to be
miraculous, maybe pushed us to the edge of credulity.
119
00:10:31,189 –> 00:10:34,440
And now we’re saying, no, no, no, they were a dream.
120
00:10:34,626 –> 00:10:47,315
Do not imagine, continues Maimonides, that an angel is seen or his word heard otherwise
than in a prophetic vision or a prophetic dream, according to the principles laid down.
121
00:10:47,315 –> 00:10:59,883
I make myself known unto him in a vision, speak unto him in a dream, and now he’s
talking from Numbers and talking about at least every prophet besides Moses.
122
00:11:00,143 –> 00:11:04,428
The instances quoted may serve as an illustration of these passages.
123
00:11:04,428 –> 00:11:05,899
Which I do not mention.
124
00:11:05,899 –> 00:11:11,802
So Maimonides is saying, I’m not gonna mention every verse, but connect the dots.
125
00:11:11,802 –> 00:11:25,030
From the rule laid down by us that prophecy requires preparation, and from our
interpretation of the homonym “angel,” you will infer that Hagar, the Egyptian woman,
126
00:11:25,030 –> 00:11:26,250
Was not a prophetess.
127
00:11:26,250 –> 00:11:28,972
Also Manoah and his wife were no prophets.
128
00:11:28,972 –> 00:11:33,404
For the speech they heard or imagined they heard was like the bat kol.
129
00:11:33,506 –> 00:11:36,287
Which is so frequently mentioned by our sages.
130
00:11:36,287 –> 00:11:40,088
That’s pretty remarkable, by the way.
131
00:11:40,088 –> 00:11:41,729
Like he knocks it down.
132
00:11:41,729 –> 00:11:44,249
To be a prophet is really special.
133
00:11:44,249 –> 00:11:48,351
All these people who we thought were prophets, Maimonides doesn’t consider prophets.
134
00:11:48,351 –> 00:11:52,212
I mean, we all know there was no prophecy at the times of the rabbis.
135
00:11:52,212 –> 00:11:53,672
They would hear a bat kol.
136
00:11:53,672 –> 00:11:55,593
And those bat kols are pretty cool.
137
00:11:55,593 –> 00:12:00,014
But what he’s doing is he’s putting it into the same category.
138
00:12:00,556 –> 00:12:07,551
This is the principal method by which most of the difficult passages in the Bible can be
explained.
139
00:12:07,551 –> 00:12:09,312
So this is getting to what you said.
140
00:12:09,312 –> 00:12:11,694
You said Maimonides is a rationalist.
141
00:12:11,694 –> 00:12:22,061
He is looking for any tools that get him away from anthropomorphism, any tools that get
him away from changes in the rules of nature and miracles.
142
00:12:22,061 –> 00:12:27,226
He’s just taking care of Balaam’s donkey, Jacob fighting with an angel.
143
00:12:27,226 –> 00:12:30,018
So it’s an interesting tool.
144
00:12:30,018 –> 00:12:32,639
But I think it’s a little bit deeper than that.
145
00:12:32,639 –> 00:12:37,959
He quoted, if you remember before, Bereshit Rabbah.
146
00:12:37,959 –> 00:12:42,041
And he said that he kind of used this as a proof text.
147
00:12:42,041 –> 00:12:48,143
He said, My Lord, please, if I have found favor in your eyes, please do not depart from
your servant.
148
00:12:48,143 –> 00:12:50,524
That is Genesis 18.
149
00:12:50,524 –> 00:12:58,306
And it is in Bereshit Rabbah that we find the text.
150
00:12:58,306 –> 00:13:10,189
That it is three angels, and what Rabbi Hiyya is saying is that he is talking to the
senior one, that is Michael.
151
00:13:10,189 –> 00:13:15,771
So again, really it’s a stretch, I think, to put this all on Rabbi Hiyya.
152
00:13:15,771 –> 00:13:26,830
But what Maimonides is doing, like many great sages, when he creates something
revolutionary, he’s trying to make it less revolutionary and put it into the words
153
00:13:26,830 –> 00:13:27,614
That’s always what they do.
154
00:13:27,624 –> 00:13:31,655
Of a sage of the Midrash.
155
00:13:31,655 –> 00:13:33,076
So he goes on.
156
00:13:33,076 –> 00:13:44,070
He says, Under such circumstances, the senses cease to act. The Active Intellect
influences the rational faculties through the imaginative faculties that become perfect
157
00:13:44,070 –> 00:13:44,880
And active.
158
00:13:44,880 –> 00:13:47,761
So he’s talking about prophecy and dreaming here.
159
00:13:47,761 –> 00:13:51,212
Sometimes the prophecy begins with a prophetic vision.
160
00:13:51,212 –> 00:13:58,406
The prophet greatly trembles and is much affected in consequence of the perfect action of
the imaginative faculty.
161
00:13:58,406 –> 00:14:00,808
And after that, the prophecy follows.
162
00:14:00,808 –> 00:14:02,729
This was the case with Abraham.
163
00:14:02,729 –> 00:14:08,572
The commencement of the prophecy is the word of the Lord came to Abraham in a vision.
164
00:14:08,572 –> 00:14:11,674
And after this, a deep sleep fell upon Abraham.
165
00:14:11,674 –> 00:14:14,905
So now we’re going to start reading these previous stories differently.
166
00:14:14,905 –> 00:14:19,798
And we’re going to see: my goodness, in this case, Abraham actually did fall asleep.
167
00:14:19,798 –> 00:14:29,425
And at last he said unto Abraham, Then when prophets speak of the fact that they received
a prophecy, they say they received it from an angel or from God.
168
00:14:29,425 –> 00:14:33,928
But even in the latter case, it was likewise received through an angel.
169
00:14:33,928 –> 00:14:38,672
So he’s saying, Don’t even listen to the protagonist.
170
00:14:38,672 –> 00:14:42,048
He might say he heard it from God, but he heard it in a dream.
171
00:14:42,048 –> 00:14:50,402
Our sages therefore explained the words, and the Lord said unto her. Now we’re talking
about last week’s parsha, about the two nations in your womb.
172
00:14:50,402 –> 00:14:54,104
So he doesn’t say it was Shem, he doesn’t say it was Abraham.
173
00:14:54,104 –> 00:14:57,726
Maimonides says he spoke through an angel.
174
00:14:57,726 –> 00:15:07,550
You must know that whenever scripture relates that the Lord or an angel spoke to a person,
this took place in a dream or a prophetic vision.
175
00:15:07,902 –> 00:15:10,763
Instances of the first form are the following.
176
00:15:10,763 –> 00:15:18,126
And the angel of the Lord said unto me in a dream, Jacob, an angel said unto Israel in a
vision of night.
177
00:15:18,126 –> 00:15:19,627
It goes on and on.
178
00:15:19,627 –> 00:15:21,408
But here is the big one.
179
00:15:21,408 –> 00:15:25,970
And an angel of the Lord called unto Abraham out of heaven the second time.
180
00:15:25,970 –> 00:15:27,470
So this is the Akedah.
181
00:15:27,470 –> 00:15:34,353
So he gave us permission to connect the dots, but he’s not going to let this one fall
away.
182
00:15:34,353 –> 00:15:37,096
He is saying that the Akedah was a dream.
183
00:15:37,096 –> 00:15:40,007
I would venture to say it was a little bit of a nightmare.
184
00:15:40,007 –> 00:15:43,928
The point was that now it changes everything.
185
00:15:43,928 –> 00:15:51,790
Because when somebody asks you, why did Abraham argue at Sodom when other people were
concerned?
186
00:15:51,790 –> 00:15:55,352
And why did he not argue when it came to his son?
187
00:15:55,352 –> 00:15:57,312
You have to put Abraham on the couch.
188
00:15:57,312 –> 00:16:02,094
You got to put him on the couch and say, Were you still working out things with your son?
189
00:16:02,094 –> 00:16:03,974
When God said to you,
190
00:16:04,002 –> 00:16:07,925
Get your son, the son you love, your only son, get Yitzhak.
191
00:16:07,925 –> 00:16:12,329
Were you still troubled by who was going to be your heir?
192
00:16:12,329 –> 00:16:19,435
Were you still bothered by making the ultimate sacrifice to God, which is giving your
child?
193
00:16:19,435 –> 00:16:21,316
You needed to work it out.
194
00:16:21,316 –> 00:16:25,840
A dream changes everything, but it doesn’t make it less important.
195
00:16:25,840 –> 00:16:30,063
He has God saying to Noah.
196
00:16:30,063 –> 00:16:33,768
So even cases where it is Elohim.
197
00:16:33,768 –> 00:16:40,413
Maimonides takes a radical step and says that there are certain synonyms for angels.
198
00:16:40,413 –> 00:16:44,676
And some of those synonyms can even be Elohim.
199
00:16:44,676 –> 00:16:47,778
It is absolutely fascinating.
200
00:16:47,778 –> 00:16:57,496
He says in chapter 43: we have already shown in our work that the prophets sometimes
prophesy in allegories.
201
00:16:57,496 –> 00:17:01,358
They use a term allegorically, and in the same
202
00:17:01,358 –> 00:17:04,839
Prophecy, the meaning of the allegory is given.
203
00:17:04,839 –> 00:17:11,001
In our dreams, we sometimes believe that we are awake and relate a dream to another person
who explains the meaning.
204
00:17:11,001 –> 00:17:13,261
And all this goes on while we dream.
205
00:17:13,261 –> 00:17:17,258
Our sages call this a dream interpreted in a dream.
206
00:17:17,258 –> 00:17:18,863
I just love that.
207
00:17:18,863 –> 00:17:20,563
What he is…
208
00:17:20,563 –> 00:17:29,696
I think what he’s arguing, and he’s basing it on the Talmud, and we’re going to go
actually see some of the stuff in the Talmud, is that a dream interpreted in a dream,
209
00:17:29,696 –> 00:17:31,328
Rabbi, is as close to
210
00:17:31,328 –> 00:17:37,720
Saying what I was saying before, which is working out the dream, sometimes you work out
your issues.
211
00:17:37,720 –> 00:17:48,303
By going through it, by proceeding, by going through the narrative, you can sometimes
interpret your own dreams and work it out.
212
00:17:48,303 –> 00:17:56,095
So what’s interesting is, I mean, this is very, you know, middle 20th century Freud, which
is so fantastic.
213
00:17:56,095 –> 00:17:58,746
You know, it’s the importance of dreams.
214
00:17:58,746 –> 00:18:00,746
I think it’s important to say.
215
00:18:00,746 –> 00:18:06,568
That Maimonides is not minimizing the test of the Akedah.
216
00:18:06,568 –> 00:18:10,330
He’s not saying that Avraham wasn’t tested.
217
00:18:10,330 –> 00:18:15,172
He’s just saying that it was a strong test, even though it didn’t really happen.
218
00:18:15,172 –> 00:18:17,733
It’s hard for us to understand that.
219
00:18:17,733 –> 00:18:20,014
Because if it didn’t really happen, what’s the test?
220
00:18:20,014 –> 00:18:29,888
But if you take dreams as being real, clearly the way he’s saying them, then even the
dream of sacrificing his son was a huge test.
221
00:18:29,984 –> 00:18:31,795
Absolutely, absolutely.
222
00:18:31,795 –> 00:18:40,200
But I love that you know connect it to the obvious, which is the 20th century, where we,
the Western world, discover dreams.
223
00:18:40,200 –> 00:18:42,301
Look what he says a little bit later.
224
00:18:42,301 –> 00:18:54,154
He says, the prophets, however, are also shown things which do not illustrate the object
of the vision, but indicate it by their name through its etymology or homonymity.
225
00:18:54,154 –> 00:18:57,288
Have you heard of a Freudian pun?
226
00:18:57,288 –> 00:19:08,650
Have you heard of the mind getting a message underneath the defenses of your id or your
ego by using a word that can mean two things?
227
00:19:08,650 –> 00:19:20,741
Thus, the imaginative faculty forms the image of a thing, the name of which has two
meanings, one of which denotes something different from the image.
228
00:19:21,002 –> 00:19:22,403
Just blew me away.
229
00:19:22,403 –> 00:19:31,049
And let’s remember we’re listening to a doctor, someone who was an observer of the human
condition.
230
00:19:31,049 –> 00:19:32,310
I just love it.
231
00:19:32,310 –> 00:19:41,962
So he does quote the Talmud, and I thought we might just visit a little bit the Talmud,
because the Talmud does have a lot of things to say about dreams.
232
00:19:41,962 –> 00:19:42,717
In Bavli.
233
00:19:42,717 –> 00:19:45,980
Specifically at the end of Berakhot, where you’re quoting from.
234
00:19:45,980 –> 00:19:49,642
So it’s like all the discussion of dreams or most of the discussion of dreams.
235
00:19:49,642 –> 00:19:51,520
Appears then at the end of Talmud Berakhot.
236
00:19:51,520 –> 00:19:52,636
Okay, take it away.
237
00:19:52,636 –> 00:19:53,638
Absolutely.
238
00:19:55,264 –> 00:19:58,816
And now a word from our sponsor.
239
00:19:58,976 –> 00:20:04,679
If there’s one thing we value at Madlik Podcast, it’s reading texts and talking about
them.
240
00:20:04,679 –> 00:20:09,382
That’s why I’m excited to share something I created called VoiceGift PLAY.
241
00:20:09,402 –> 00:20:14,305
It fits in the palm of your hand like a remote control and clips onto any book.
242
00:20:14,305 –> 00:20:20,308
It’s inspired by those old school museum audio guides, but this is personal.
243
00:20:20,308 –> 00:20:23,392
VoiceGift PLAY stores up to 10 hours of audio.
244
00:20:23,392 –> 00:20:27,685
Across 999 numbered recordings.
245
00:20:27,706 –> 00:20:35,252
You simply enter a number to record a comment, memory, or explanation, and enter the same
number to play it back.
246
00:20:35,252 –> 00:20:45,100
It’s perfect for b’nai mitzvah practicing their leining, capturing Grandpa’s favorite
tune, or recording Chad Gadya in a voice that matters.
247
00:20:45,160 –> 00:20:47,583
Go to voice.gift.
248
00:20:47,583 –> 00:20:50,725
That’s www.voice.gift.
249
00:20:52,134 –> 00:20:55,915
And use code MADLIK for fifteen percent off.
250
00:20:56,196 –> 00:20:56,956
Thanks.
251
00:20:56,956 –> 00:20:59,677
And now back to our podcast.
252
00:21:00,918 –> 00:21:05,680
The Gemara relates, Ameimar and Mar Zutra and Rav Ashi were sitting together.
253
00:21:05,680 –> 00:21:10,172
They said, Let each and every one of us say something that the other has not heard.
254
00:21:10,172 –> 00:21:11,762
They’re gonna make a hiddush.
255
00:21:11,762 –> 00:21:21,016
One of them began and said, One who saw a dream and does not know what he saw, should
stand before the priests when they lift their hands
256
00:21:21,016 –> 00:21:24,148
During the priestly blessing, and say the following.
257
00:21:24,148 –> 00:21:35,757
Now, for those of you who use a traditional siddur, Rabbi, you will confirm that this
actually is in traditional siddurim up until today.
258
00:21:35,757 –> 00:21:46,725
That because the Talmud believes that if you have a dream that needs to be explained,
you need to go to the Kohanim, when do we get exposed to the Kohanim?
259
00:21:46,725 –> 00:21:47,958
When they duchan.
260
00:21:47,958 –> 00:21:53,080
So it says, go ahead and say this, and it’s actually in the siddur.
261
00:21:53,080 –> 00:21:58,843
And it has the following prayer: Master of the Universe, I am yours and my dreams are
yours.
262
00:21:58,843 –> 00:22:02,244
I dreamed a dream and I do not know what it is.
263
00:22:02,244 –> 00:22:11,878
Whether I have dreamed of myself, whether my friends have dreamed of me, or whether I have
dreamed of others, if the dreams are good, strengthen them and reinforce them like the
264
00:22:11,878 –> 00:22:13,189
Dreams of Joseph.
265
00:22:13,189 –> 00:22:16,512
And if the dreams require healing, heal them.
266
00:22:16,512 –> 00:22:26,691
Like the bitter waters of Marah by Moses our teacher, and like Miriam from her leprosy,
and like Hezekiah from his illness, and like the bitter waters of Jericho by Elisha.
267
00:22:26,691 –> 00:22:35,357
And just as you transform the curse of Balaam the wicked into a blessing, so transform all
of my dreams for me for the best.
268
00:22:35,378 –> 00:22:45,280
And now he’s talking to the guy who’s saying this while the Kohanim are duchening. He
should complete his prayer together with the priests.
269
00:22:45,280 –> 00:22:52,914
So that the congregation responds amen both to the blessing of the priests and to his
request.
270
00:22:52,914 –> 00:22:57,315
He’s repurposing the amen of the congregation.
271
00:22:57,336 –> 00:23:02,628
And if not, he says a shorter version so he can get it all in.
272
00:23:02,628 –> 00:23:06,180
This is just wonderful, wonderful stuff.
273
00:23:06,180 –> 00:23:11,362
And I think, Rabbi, you know, you don’t have to be a wordsmith and use a homonym.
274
00:23:11,362 –> 00:23:19,208
Dreams are what we do when we dream at night when we sleep, but they also are aspirations
in both languages, I think.
275
00:23:19,208 –> 00:23:22,720
And so that makes it also a very beautiful prayer.
276
00:23:22,720 –> 00:23:33,578
Another piece of Talmud says as follows: Rabbi Yohanan also said, Three dreams are
fulfilled: a dream of the morning, a dream that one’s fellow dreamed about him, and a
277
00:23:33,578 –> 00:23:35,840
Dream that is interpreted within a dream.
278
00:23:35,840 –> 00:23:38,982
So this is what
279
00:23:41,773 –> 00:23:46,937
This is what Maimonides used above.
280
00:23:46,937 –> 00:23:53,043
And some say that a dream that is repeated several times is also fulfilled.
281
00:23:53,043 –> 00:23:54,404
Guess what?
282
00:23:54,404 –> 00:23:56,166
That’s a recurring dream.
283
00:23:56,166 –> 00:23:57,948
We have those too.
284
00:23:57,948 –> 00:24:00,630
We’re trying to work something out.
285
00:24:00,630 –> 00:24:04,731
Mine is I’m still trying to get to that class at Columbia.
286
00:24:04,731 –> 00:24:05,861
I can’t find it.
287
00:24:05,861 –> 00:24:08,992
I’m gonna get incomplete and I’m not gonna graduate.
288
00:24:08,992 –> 00:24:11,613
I’m still trying to work that one out.
289
00:24:11,853 –> 00:24:20,055
Rabbi Shmuel bar Nahmani said that Rabbi Yonatan said, a person is shown in his dreams
only the thoughts of his heart.
290
00:24:20,055 –> 00:24:22,196
Now you can’t get stronger than this.
291
00:24:22,196 –> 00:24:26,013
You are shown in a dream the thoughts of your heart.
292
00:24:26,013 –> 00:24:26,877
Right.
293
00:24:26,877 –> 00:24:30,718
What you’re really thinking comes out in your dreams.
294
00:24:31,078 –> 00:24:35,342
Ein mar’in lo la-adam ella me-hirhurei libo.
295
00:24:35,342 –> 00:24:39,405
Just beautiful and profound and true.
296
00:24:39,405 –> 00:24:45,190
And you don’t need to be a psychoanalyst to say that.
297
00:24:45,190 –> 00:24:47,672
How will you know the thoughts of your heart?
298
00:24:47,672 –> 00:24:50,215
By their being revealed to you in a dream.
299
00:24:50,215 –> 00:24:59,286
Rava said, know that this is the case, for one is neither shown a golden palm tree nor an
elephant going through the eye of a needle in a dream.
300
00:24:59,286 –> 00:25:04,611
In other words, dreams only contain images that enter a person’s mind.
301
00:25:04,611 –> 00:25:15,239
So, first of all, for those of you who are thinking maybe there’s something from the New
Testament that sounds similar to this, remember when Jesus said a rich man
302
00:25:15,239 –> 00:25:20,504
Is as likely to go to heaven as a camel passing through the eye of a needle.
303
00:25:20,504 –> 00:25:23,947
So now at least we know this was a figure of speech.
304
00:25:23,947 –> 00:25:27,682
If you want to say something can never happen,
305
00:25:27,682 –> 00:25:31,023
Get a big animal and try to fit it through the eye of a needle.
306
00:25:31,023 –> 00:25:43,696
But for the purposes at hand, what Rava is saying is the mind is grappling with concepts
that are within it, it’s repurposing them, it’s repositioning them, it’s trying to help
307
00:25:43,696 –> 00:25:46,287
You work out situations.
308
00:25:46,287 –> 00:25:48,508
And it’s just beautiful.
309
00:25:48,898 –> 00:25:55,298
The Gemara continues: related to what was said above, that one should pray for a good
dream.
310
00:25:55,298 –> 00:26:01,486
The Gemara cites additional maxims concerning dreams and their interpretation.
311
00:26:01,486 –> 00:26:05,752
Rav Hisda said one should see any dream and not a fast.
312
00:26:05,752 –> 00:26:09,697
In other words, any dream is preferable to a dream during a fast.
313
00:26:09,697 –> 00:26:13,982
So this is as close as it gets to dreaming when you’re under the influence.
314
00:26:13,982 –> 00:26:16,643
Or in this case, you’re not under the influence.
315
00:26:16,643 –> 00:26:20,602
You’ve been fasting, your mind is wandering.
316
00:26:20,602 –> 00:26:23,786
Not a great time to dream.
317
00:26:23,786 –> 00:26:29,588
Well, I mean your mind is wandering, therefore you may be more prone to dreams.
318
00:26:29,688 –> 00:26:32,069
Yep.
319
00:26:32,069 –> 00:26:38,572
So they understand that the chemical balance in your body can affect your dreams.
320
00:26:38,572 –> 00:26:43,756
And Rav Hisda said, a dream not interpreted is like a letter
321
00:26:43,756 –> 00:26:44,607
not read.
322
00:26:44,607 –> 00:26:46,828
You can’t get better than that, Rabbi.
323
00:26:46,828 –> 00:26:50,506
I mean, that’s as close to a Hallmark card as you can get.
324
00:26:50,506 –> 00:26:55,515
A dream not interpreted is like a letter not read.
325
00:26:55,515 –> 00:26:59,358
As long as it is not interpreted, it cannot be fulfilled.
326
00:26:59,358 –> 00:27:02,741
And the interpretation of a dream creates its meaning.
327
00:27:02,741 –> 00:27:09,868
Rav Hisda said a good dream is not entirely fulfilled, and a bad dream is not entirely
fulfilled.
328
00:27:09,868 –> 00:27:13,720
Maimonides actually says that there’s always going to be some chaff.
329
00:27:13,720 –> 00:27:16,058
You don’t have to explain everything.
330
00:27:16,058 –> 00:27:25,004
The mind is trying to get its lesson past your gatekeepers.
331
00:27:25,004 –> 00:27:29,406
And to do that, it’s gotta embellish or add to the story.
332
00:27:29,406 –> 00:27:38,550
Rav Hisda said, a bad dream is preferable to a good dream, as a bad dream causes one to
feel remorse and to repent.
333
00:27:38,550 –> 00:27:39,710
I like that.
334
00:27:39,724 –> 00:27:40,694
That’s good also.
335
00:27:40,694 –> 00:27:47,440
I mean, you know, these Gemaras are good when they give you something that’s surprising,
something you don’t expect.
336
00:27:48,061 –> 00:27:49,763
So the next one gets even better.
337
00:27:49,763 –> 00:27:50,724
I like the next one.
338
00:27:50,724 –> 00:27:55,228
Rav Hisda said, A bad dream, his sadness is enough for him.
339
00:27:55,228 –> 00:27:58,351
A good dream, his joy is enough for him.
340
00:27:58,351 –> 00:28:07,212
So what that means to say, Rabbi, is if you have a dream and something terrible happens to
you, that terrible thing doesn’t have to happen to you anymore.
341
00:28:07,212 –> 00:28:08,883
Because you’ve already suffered.
342
00:28:08,883 –> 00:28:13,647
You’ve already experienced it, so to speak, in the dream.
343
00:28:13,647 –> 00:28:16,890
So it saves you all this actual anguish.
344
00:28:16,890 –> 00:28:20,933
But on the other hand, a good dream, you just got your reward.
345
00:28:20,933 –> 00:28:23,154
You dreamed of winning a lottery ticket.
346
00:28:23,154 –> 00:28:24,695
You were ecstatic.
347
00:28:24,695 –> 00:28:25,306
Guess what?
348
00:28:25,306 –> 00:28:28,998
You don’t have to win a real lottery ticket anymore.
349
00:28:29,479 –> 00:28:33,452
Rav Yosef said, even for me, the joy of a good dream negates it.
350
00:28:33,452 –> 00:28:39,465
Meaning to say, once you have the good dream, you don’t have to have the experience
anymore.
351
00:28:39,465 –> 00:28:42,106
These are, as you say, gems.
352
00:28:42,106 –> 00:28:45,107
And the rabbis go on.
353
00:28:45,107 –> 00:28:59,456
But what I want to conclude with is I want to touch base with Freud, Jung, and Otto Rank,
because each in their own way took some of the ideas that we are playing with and
354
00:28:59,456 –> 00:29:05,569
Now that we have the perspective of seeing it in the Torah, I think we can appreciate them
better.
355
00:29:05,569 –> 00:29:09,672
So Freud made the dream a way into the unconscious.
356
00:29:09,672 –> 00:29:21,418
It’s clear from the text that we’ve seen that even the sages of the Talmud understood
that you can resolve certain things in a dream that you might not be able to
357
00:29:21,418 –> 00:29:28,886
resolve in the light of day, because you’re using puns, because you’re getting
through the gatekeepers.
358
00:29:28,886 –> 00:29:36,148
So the idea of associations, all of these tools were there with the rabbis.
359
00:29:36,148 –> 00:29:43,810
Jung, who was much more interested in culture, extended the comparison from the individual
to the culture.
360
00:29:43,810 –> 00:29:53,153
He studied the mythical images that appeared in patients’ dreams and fantasies and
compared them with the symbols of ancient religions and myths.
361
00:29:53,153 –> 00:29:57,506
So Jung actually, although Freud did it in Moses and Monotheism,
362
00:29:57,506 –> 00:30:11,774
But Jung actually went to how we retell our mythologies, we retell the stories of our
scripture, and use these to help us resolve the conflicts within them.
363
00:30:11,774 –> 00:30:16,037
But the thinker that fascinates me the most is Otto Rank.
364
00:30:16,037 –> 00:30:25,314
And he was one of Freud’s close associates, and he proposed that myths could be read
through the method of dream interpretation.
365
00:30:25,314 –> 00:30:29,155
He called myth a dream of the masses of the people.
366
00:30:29,155 –> 00:30:42,979
He actually went as far as I think Maimonides did, which he says you have to look at the
story itself as a cumulative dream, a myth of a people that gives us a striking parallel
367
00:30:42,979 –> 00:30:45,780
To the question we’re asking about the Torah.
368
00:30:45,780 –> 00:30:54,972
Reading a biblical story preserves a culture’s struggle with an idea, the way a dream can
disclose a person’s inner conflict.
369
00:30:55,146 –> 00:30:57,707
And I kind of just love that.
370
00:30:57,707 –> 00:31:02,308
And I couldn’t help but think, Rabbi, I just got back from Israel.
371
00:31:02,308 –> 00:31:10,450
And it’s almost as though the whole country is still reliving a nightmare, the nightmare
of October 7th.
372
00:31:10,450 –> 00:31:18,252
And yes, in the case of October 7th, it actually happened, but now everyone is reliving it
and trying to solve it.
373
00:31:18,252 –> 00:31:19,833
It becomes a dream.
374
00:31:19,833 –> 00:31:24,734
It becomes something that is with you when you’re awake and when you’re asleep.
375
00:31:24,746 –> 00:31:33,614
And when they say over time is the healing, I think part of the time is not static time,
but dynamic time of processing it.
376
00:31:33,614 –> 00:31:44,965
And I think, yes, going back to an Akedah or in our week’s parsha, leaving home, which is
what Jacob is doing, never going to see his mother again.
377
00:31:44,965 –> 00:31:46,784
He is dealing with things.
378
00:31:46,784 –> 00:31:52,880
And he has this vision of a sulam, of a ladder with angels going up and going down.
379
00:31:52,880 –> 00:31:56,503
And that helps him deal with these problems.
380
00:31:56,503 –> 00:32:05,221
And when he lands back on the other end of the journey, he has another dream that is
transformative and helps him deal with this.
381
00:32:05,221 –> 00:32:13,548
So I just think it’s wonderful that Otto Rank really sees it not simply as yes, we can
take this at a personal level.
382
00:32:13,548 –> 00:32:27,578
But actually looks at the Torah the way Maimonides does and says we are selling ourselves
short if we don’t read some of these narratives as our social heritage of a dream, our
383
00:32:27,578 –> 00:32:38,255
Combined dream that when we discuss around that Shabbos table, we are reliving,
reprocessing, and trying to deal with issues that never seem to go away.
384
00:32:38,415 –> 00:32:39,136
Fantastic.
385
00:32:39,136 –> 00:32:42,808
This was great, a little unexpected, and that’s why it’s really good.
386
00:32:42,808 –> 00:32:43,488
Thank you, Geoffrey.
387
00:32:43,488 –> 00:32:44,739
Shabbat shalom to everybody.
388
00:32:44,739 –> 00:32:47,782
Next week we have a special treat, Thanksgiving.
389
00:32:47,782 –> 00:32:51,624
Everything you want to know about Thanksgiving in Jewish tradition.
390
00:32:51,624 –> 00:32:52,965
Rabbi Michael Broyde.
391
00:32:52,965 –> 00:32:55,077
We will have Rabbi Michael Broyde back.
392
00:32:55,077 –> 00:32:58,129
So if you have any questions, send them to us.
393
00:32:58,129 –> 00:33:01,051
Are turkeys kosher? We will find out.
394
00:33:01,051 –> 00:33:05,534
Did the idea of having a meal of thanks come from Halacha?
395
00:33:05,534 –> 00:33:06,975
We will find out.
396
00:33:06,975 –> 00:33:09,236
See you all next week.



